Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe Menu

Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe offers a straightforward, no-frills menu centered around fresh, thoughtfully prepared seafood. The selection reflects a market-style approach with takeout convenience, focusing on dishes that feel at home whether you’re grabbing a quick, satisfying lunch or packing a casual dinner to enjoy by the water.

Popular choices include crisp shrimp baskets, fresh crab cakes, and vibrant seafood salads, each made with ingredients that highlight the natural flavors of the ocean. These items pair well with the relaxed vibe of Shelter Island, inviting you to savor something simple yet well-crafted amidst an easygoing atmosphere.

Meals here fit naturally into the rhythm of a laid-back day—perfect for a midday break after exploring local sights or winding down with a quiet evening by the shore. The straightforward menu keeps the experience approachable, matching the friendly service and welcoming setting that defines Commander Cody’s.